Planet Detroit: House bill would expand FEMA coverage for flooded, moldy Michigan basements: ‘There needs to be some equity’

Overview:

– U.S. House bill introduced by Rep. Rashida Tlaib seeks to expand FEMA assistance eligibility and coverage, including full basement damage and mold mitigation.
– FEMA policy for basements covers damaged furnaces and water heaters. Personal property, carpeting, and furniture are not covered.
– “There needs to be some equity in terms of what FEMA will pay for,” says Kristin Taylor, a WSU political science professor.

As a queen mattress surfed past her house, Barb Matney struggled to keep her composure. In a matter of hours, nearly 6 inches of rain had fallen across Metro Detroit, filling her basement with stormwater and forcing neighbors to discard their waterlogged furniture and belongings onto the curb.

“I stood in my kitchen window and I was so afraid,” recalled Matney, who lives in the Warrendale neighborhood on Detroit’s west side. “You could hear it in my voice, I was almost getting ready to burst out into tears.”

In the aftermath of the August 2014 storm, Matney said, her family lost “$52,000 worth of stuff,” including her furnace, water heater, washer, and dryer.

One of the most upsetting aspects of the storm, she says, was the loss of her college-age son’s clothes, furniture, and belongings. Until the flood, he stored his keepsakes in their basement.

When it comes to basement flooding, households across the United States have limited reimbursement opportunities for belongings and structures damaged by stormwater. That’s because disaster aid and insurance administered by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, or FEMA, does not cover personal property kept in basements.

For Matney and thousands of other Southeast Michigan residents, that means they’re excluded from receiving additional dollars to completely address the flood damage inside of their homes.

HUD estimates there was $142 million of unmet need following the 2021 flood. The city received $57 million from a Congressional appropriation after the flood, according to a 2022 city report.

An estimated 32,000 to 47,000 households, 82% which were low-to-moderate income, were directly impacted by the 2021 disaster, majority of those located in City Council Districts 4, 6, and 7.

A bill introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives this summer aims to address the ongoing issue while targeting the lingering health impacts of flooding.

In July, U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib, a Detroit Democrat, introduced H.R. 4774, the Fix Our Flooded Basements Act, to expand federal disaster aid coverage for repair and replacement costs due to basement flooding damage, and provide funds for mold and mildew remediation.

“I really want to ensure the maximum amount of federal disaster assistance for our families for immediate recovery,” Tlaib told Planet Detroit. “The goal is to cover the whole house and make sure basements are covered.”

FEMA’s work must reflect Midwest climate risk, Tlaib says

Tlaib introduced the bill because of the number of residents in her district who have reached out to her in search of help for the hazards in their basement, she said.

Two years out from the August 2023 flood, the last federally declared emergency in Southeast Michigan, Tlaib said she’s still receiving calls about toxic mold.

“It is so bizarre as a member of Congress, finding out that FEMA will come and cover getting a new furnace or water heater, but won’t actually cover the actual mitigation and cleaning up of the sewage and the water in people’s basements,” Tlaib said at an Aug. 19 news conference about the bill.

Federal policy offers limited coverage for basement damage, she added, ignoring the prevalence and importance of basements in regions outside of traditional natural disaster areas.

“FEMA was created, for many reasons, for coastal communities, but now the Midwest is directly impacted by those doing nothing about the climate crisis, and so we have to make sure that all these federal agencies are adapting to that and not leaving communities like ours behind.”

The Fix Our Flooded Basements bill would change language in the Stafford Act, a federal law that oversees FEMA disaster relief, to expand eligibility and coverage under the agency’s insurance policies and assistance funds and for mold remediation and flooding damage to basement appliances, carpet flooring, and personal property. 

At the moment, there is no action on Tlaib’s bill. Since introduction, it’s been referred to the House Committees on Financial Services and Transportation and Infrastructure.

If the bill becomes law, homeowners with flooded basement damage would be able to utilize FEMA’s Individuals and Households Program, which provides up to $43,600 for temporary housing, home repairs, and hazard mitigation. The Fix Our Flooded Basements Bill would also expand eligibility for FEMA’s Group Flood Insurance Policy.

‘There needs to be some equity’

An amendment to the Stafford Act, which was last updated in 2018, would reflect the ever-changing climate reality for communities such as Metro Detroit, said Kristin Taylor, a political science professor at Wayne State University, who studies the politics of natural disasters and disaster recovery efforts.

“There needs to be some equity in terms of what FEMA will pay for,” said Taylor. “If everything that FEMA is doing is geared towards reimbursing costs for people who live in hurricane prone areas, then it’s definitely an inequity compared to people who don’t.”

Severe rainstorms compound on the region’s histories of redlining as well as the ongoing stormwater infrastructure problems, she added.

The Fix Our Flooded Basements Bill so far has received endorsements from nearly a dozen local community organizations, as well as sponsorships from 22 U.S. representatives, including U.S. Rep. Shri Thanedar (D-Detroit).

“Flooding is one of the top concerns I hear about from my constituents,” Thanedar said in a statement. “Just 1 inch of water can cause up to $25,000 in damage and leave families with long-term health risks from black mold.”

LeJuan Council, founder and director of Detroit Area Disaster Recovery Group, has witnessed it firsthand. She’s spent the last decade addressing environmental and public health issues such as groundwater flooding, sewer backups, and mold exposure throughout the city.

Many city residents not only store their belongings in their basements, but use them as a living space, Council said. The Stafford Act doesn’t account for this, nor does it directly assist with the mold and mildew problems that residents experience long after the storm.

“When you see that visual of everybody’s belongings curb to curb, with their things piled up 4 feet tall and 10 feet wide, that stuff will never get paid for and that’s hard because (that’s) $30,000, $40,000, $50,000 worth of stuff,” she said.

You can read the full article here.